Residents Call for Resignation of Moon Officials

Questions linger about the residency of Supervisor Tim McLaughlin and Manager Jeanne Creese. Residents also want the board to block a new group home on Greenlea Drive.

When Greenlea Drive resident Greg Thompson approached the podium at last night's Moon Board of Supervisors meeting, he said he had a proposition for township Manager Jeanne Creese. 

"I have a house for you," he said. "Move right next door to me. At 162 Greenlea Drive." 

Thompson was among more than a dozen Moon residents who spoke at the contentious meeting, which ended with the board taking a vote to terminate Creese from her position. The vote did not pass.

Residents jammed the township meeting room and criticized the board over a variety of issues during the three-hour meeting. Some called for Creese to resign from her position because Some questioned why Supervisor Tim McLaughlin has not stepped down from the board after . And many came to the meeting requesting that the board stop a group home for the mentally ill from  

The board held an executive session after adjourning the meeting. 

Group home opposed

Residents from the neighborhood again asked the board to prevent a group home for the mentally ill from opening on Greenlea Drive.

In October, the Homestead-based Transitional Services Inc. purchased a single-family house on the street to use as a group home for people with mental illnesses.  Sharon Alberts, CEO of the organization, said the home would open in the next several months.

Neighbors have expressed concern that the home’s residents would pose a safety risk to children on the street. One man brought a photograph of Jared Loughner, the 22-year-old Arizona man charged with shooting 12 people, including U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, in January.

He told the board the photograph was meant to demonstrate what can happen when a mentally ill person forgets to take medication. 

Residents requested that an occupancy permit issued to Transitional Services be revoked. But township Solicitor Blaine Lucas said the matter was out of the board’s hands.

He said the township zoning hearing board would hear an appeal regarding the permit at its March 10 meeting. 

“The township received an application and was obligated to act on that based on the considerations of the federal Fair Housing Act,” Lucas said.  “Any property owner also has legal rights. There is a process in place.”

McLaughlin said he hoped the township would  investigate Transitional Services and its use of the home. 

"Where do these people go after the home?" McLaughlin said of the house's future residents. "A maximum-security prison probably with guards." 

Alberts said no one with a known criminal background would be accepted into the home.

Supervisor's residency questioned

Moon resident Carole Masri asked McLaughlin, a US Airways employee who was transferred to North Carolina several months ago, “why he’s holding his seat hostage.”

“We need a resident who is here daily,” she said. “Since he’s going to be giving up his seat in December, why does he stay? Does he have a purpose? I have no idea.”

McLaughlin, whose home at 111 Snell Drive is listed for sale through Prudential Real Estate, said he has no plans to resign from the board. He said he has not decided if he will seek re-election after his term expires in December.

"I will not be resigning from the position because of nights like this,” McLaughlin said, referring to the packed meeting room.  He indicated that US Airways may shift  his job back to the Pittsburgh area in the coming months.

“If my home sells, I still have a brother and sister-in-law who live in Moon,” he said. “I’ll look to establishing residency at their home.”

Lucas said the board does not have the power to remove McLaughlin from his position based on his residency status. 

"The board has no authority to act in that regard," he said. 

Creese retains position

Supervisor Frank Sinatra called for the board to terminate Creese from her position as manager. McLaughlin and Sinatra voted in favor of removing her, while Supervisors Jim Vitale, Marv Eicher and Andrew Gribben voted to retain her. 

Creese, who was appointed to her position in March 2009, lives in Rochester, Beaver County. She said she has been unable to sell her home and that she was not told she needed to move into the township at the time she was appointed. 

She said ongoing personnel issues in the township have prevented her from speaking on-the-record about her residency status. 

"I can't sit here and hear that I've failed to do something that is not in my control," she said. "If I'm going to be dismissed it will not be performance-based." 

Christine March 03, 2011 at 07:15 PM
Her nonresidency has possibly created an issue in Amherst, would she be as willing to allow these type of development to happen if she was a resident of Moon Township. The residents of this neighborhood our concerned with what is happening and Tim McLaughlin and Frank Sinatra are at least sympathetic to their cause. This manager is incontrol of the daily activities of the township and our taxpayer money. Yes, I beleive all members of the board should be residents, but when I go to the Municipal Building I deal with the staff and I am questioning whether this manager has the communities best interest in mind. And I have to disagree with her that this is not performace related it has possibly efected her ability to manage the amherst issue.
clearfield March 04, 2011 at 04:33 PM
Ms. Creese is not required to live in the township. Read the township code, folks. All it says is when she can do so, she needs to do it. As with McLaughlin who lives in NC, he cannot sell his house, either. He knows how difficult it is, yet he wants to terminate her contract, along with Sinatra, when she has a residence she cannot sell. These two clowns are hypocrites. Both are unfit to serve the township. They lack logical thinking processes. The issue for Amherst Acres is zoning. The zoning ordinances are failing our community. They are not restrictive enough, i.e. Walmart, group homes, Marcellus Shale, etc. Creese could be fired at the majority's whim. What kind of deal is that? McLaughlin demonstrates egocentric, and delusional behavior. His unethical behavior is not what the township needs. He needs to resign.
Moon Future March 10, 2011 at 04:33 PM
Ms. Creese is not a member of this community and needs to resign from her Manager position. I pay taxes here and the people in charge of my money should pay taxes here. She is violating an ordinance that she must make a fair effort to move in the community. If you listen to the January supervisors meeting she said that her house was for sale. In the February she said that her house was never on the market. What are we the residents to beleive? She also alluded that she would sue the township and and residents in her statement made in the March Meeting if she was terminated. I agree with alot of what is said on this blog, but at this point the township has to move forward and replace our township manger - she can not be trusted.
Sean March 16, 2011 at 10:57 PM
Is Clarabel the clown available for township meetings Vitale is a waste of a suit and a seat on this board. Totally emabarassing his non actions dealing with Amherst does he have anything up stairs or is Eicher just moving his mouth with his hand like a puppet. Vitale is nothing but a figure head and offers nothing to this board. Shame on you Mr. Vitale just go sell your water and leave us Moon Residents alone.
John March 22, 2011 at 01:40 PM
I do not live in Amherst but when I hear Mr. Gribbon's comments on TV they make no sense. Does he not understand the reprecussions of what is in front of him. He should of kept his mouth shut on this issue just like he does on everthing else. Marv should be emabarassed to have run with Mr. Gribbon. We need responsible people in office and Mr. Gribbon has shown he can not think for himself on the Township Manager or Amherst. The people of Moon deserve better.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »